Published on: January 24, 2025
Whose Problem Are Fakeshops?
By: Johannes Elias Alder
The Deutschlandticket costs 58 euros. Not less. And certainly not much, much less. Why is that? The Deutschlandticket is a state steering instrument subsidized by public funds, intended to accelerate the traffic turnaround and financially relieve citizens. Of course, 58 euros per month is still a lot of money, so why not take an offer found via Google search, on Ebay classifieds, or on Facebook where, for example, a ticket costs only 30 euros?
The answer is short and clear: Because such offers definitely hide fraudulent structures. Deutschlandticket.de as a provider has already done a lot to suppress such offers. But it's not that easy:
If the operators of the site are outside the EU, German authorities have little leverage. So far, so understandable. A major fake shop provider even advertises its offer on Google. All previous attempts to report this to Google, at least to stop the advertising, have failed. Why should they? Google profits significantly from the fraudulent offers, especially when they drive up the advertising price for all legal market participants. Every purchase from such a provider deprives regular market participants of revenue. And the customer? Thinks they've got a bargain. I, for example, do not believe:
- Personal address and payment data are now stored in the databases of criminal structures, I would not guarantee that they are now secure.
- In buses & trains, there is constant checking, I do not assume that the tickets issued meet industry standards and are accepted as "valid".
- So you get a cheaper ticket, which is very likely invalid, and you cannot take legal action against the providers (keyword: non-EU, false information in the imprint).
And: All Deutschlandticket revenues largely go to those who provide the actual service: The transport companies that operate buses and trains. They naturally miss out on the corresponding funds, even though more people use public transport. In the end, only the providers behind these scams win. It's as bitter as it is unfortunate. And one should not take it for granted.



